Bellafini's is widely regarded as Fond du lac's best Italian restaurant.
Here are some customer reviews Bellafini's has received in our 1st. year.

Linda Kaiser:
My husband and I were in for dinner tonight, and I have to say, it 
was wonderful!  I came to Fond du Lac from the East Coast 30 some odd years ago, and have been longing for Authentic Italian cooking since then. Even just the smells coming from the kitchen made my mouth water, and  stirred up memories long forgotten. I applaud you for your hard work, because it takes someone very special to be so meticulous about cooking, and it shows.  Or should I say, it comes through in the wonderful food you prepare.
Thank you so much for the most satisfying treat for my taste buds in 
a very long time.  I actually started to tear up because it brought 
back so many memories of my childhood.  You have got my husband and me as lifelong customers.
I sorry to say that I didn't get the name of our cute little 
waitress.  She had brown hair and some freckles, and was very sweet 
and helpful, too.
Sincerely,
PS.   Loved the music, too!

Eric:
Chris, I had to write in and tell you that you have the best food in this entire city, i am so spoiled i can not even eat anywhere else anymore. since you have opened i have been to other states and even their food does not compare, all other Italian restaurants pale in comparison. I'm glad your prices are so good or i would go broke eating out all the time. thanks man
 
Rick:
I had the Pizza Carmella and have drawn one conclusion.Il migliore cibo in citt?Il solo cibo reale italiano in citt? OR The best food in town,The only real Italian food in town.I am hooked I eat there a few times a week.You should too. 

Brian:
Thompson: I was first told about Bellafinis by a friend of mine and the Pizza was outstanding! I have since been telling everyone I can how good it was. Thanks for opening in Fond du Lac and see you soon. Brian
 
Liz :
We were told about your resturant by some one that works there & again by a doctor when my husband was in the hospital. He couldn't say enough good things about it. We had to stop in and try it. The food was fantastic and the service excellent!!! Keep up the good work.
 
Lisa:
I stopped in for the first time two weeks ago - amazing pizza - it is by far the best I have had in years. Thanks for coming to Fond du Lac. 15-

scott  :
Best pizzaria gocery in Wisconsin. Chris keep up the good work 

Adam Herritz:
Absolutley wonderful atmosphere and food, I have not yet had a meal that I wasn't completley astonished by...as me and my friend say On the 7th day God rested, and it was good...on the 8th day he ate Bellafini's, and it was fantastic. 

Joe:
I tryed your sausage sandwich todayIt was as good as New York/New Jerseywhich iam from also your white pie was great. 

Max Hardcore:
YYYYYeeeeeeaaaaahhhh. That's good!!!!! 

Christiana:
I may gain a few pounds eating here too often, but it will be well worth it. I have visited Italy once, but now I can go there anytime. A PRESTO! 

sarah cary:
some of the best pizza I have every had

julie: we used to drive all the way to Sheboygan for great pizza at Il Ritrovo till we stopped in at Bellafini's no joke your pizza was the best we have ever had! and we are so glad you saved us the trip. thanks

Scott and Jenn H.:
Good Morning Mr. Giaimo - My husband and I enjoyed a wonderful dinner at Bellafini's last night and I wanted to let you know how impressed we are! My husband had the Authentic Philly Cheesesteak sandwich and could not say enough great things about it. I had the Authentic Gyro sandwich and I have to tell you, I have been to many places in Wisconsin for a Gyro and this is by FAR the best Gyro I have ever had. We look forward to dining at Bellafini's again in the very near future and plan to tell everyone we know about our wonderful dining experience.

Karen:
We stopped in tonight for the first time and ordered the "The Spataro Special" Oh my it is the best pizza I have had ever. Keep up the good work, it is so exciting to have REAL Italian food. We will be back soon to try more of what is on your menu.

jill:
I was in Sunday and I was so impressed with the pizza! I did not know what to expect, but after my visit to Bellafini's next time i am craving a pizza i know where i will go! I am excited to try the Zuppa and Pizza by the slice! Take care and keep up the awesome menu!

Mike:
First time customers today and we loved our pizza so much I had to come to your website and leave a message!! We haven't had pizza with such fresh ingredients and perfect crust in a very long time and certainly not in Fondy! And the cannolis....oh my....we will be back for those for sure. Thanks!!! Keep up the great work!

TB:
Chris - we have been to our place over 20 times and have never been disappointed. The deli is growing and I see..so has business. Keep up the great work and consistant products...be safe, TB
 
Katie:
Your food and service is always excellent. It is the best Italian I have had. Thank you!!!!!! 

Jay:
I have to say you guys make the best meatballs I have ever had. On a Pizza or in a Sandwich they are excellent. And so far everythng else I've had there is almost as good. 

The kid :
Hey you guys are great you cant beat how good your food is for the price. I tell everyone I know about the place. Hope you do well! 

Heather:
So far the word of mouth around town is giving you rave reviews! I agree its great to see some diversity in our "little" Fond du Lac. I can't wait to try everything out! Best of luck and see you soon. 

Carmina:
Chris, what a lovely place and food.  

Tyrone:
We live around the corner and couldnt be more proud to have such a great alternative to all the commercial pizza places in town. Probably the freshes pizzas we have had, will be a long time customer. And dont forget, the deli is great to, we have used them for hard to find italian meats and cheeses....
 
scott:
Hey Chris Great food! I'll be in tonite for a pizza. Scott the stew man 

bob kelso:
My wife and I just get back from a trip to Florence, Italy. I stopped in to buy fish from Brian Carter at Fond du Lac Fish. He tells me to check out the new Italian deli. So we picked up a couple of pizzas. They were great. Chris at Bellafini's is serving up the real thing! Fresh ingredients and an incredible crust. As good or better than any pizza we had in Florence. Best thing going in Fond du Lac. Looking forward to checking out the whole menu. We will spread the news about the best pizza in town. bob

Kris:
Wow! We had the pizza and it was delicious! The best in FDL for sure! Looking forward to trying the sandwiches, desserts, and shopping your grocery goods!I'll tell everyone I know how wonderful your pizza was!Good Luck!Ciao! 

John :
I ate your pizza the other day and just had to tell you I used to live in NY and Chicago and definitly think your pizza stands up to the best they have to offer. Thanks for coming to Fond du lac! .

Lisa: My daughter Julia & I came in on Tuesday and had your pizza. It was AWESOME! I came back tonight and had your meatball sandwich and that was equally as good! I can't wait to try more! Welcome to Fond du Lac! 

New York Davin: I thought I might have seen the Soprano's out front the other day

Scott, Shelia, Kayla, Justin :
Chris, Mary, Jenny, Bella & Sofie,Good luck to your family from our family. We can honestly say that we have had everything on the menu, we come in at least once a week & still dream of eating the fabulous food that you create! We enjoy coming down for desert and just visiting with you as well! We can't wait to make Lasagna this fall with some of the products from your store! You guys are the BEST! 

Diane:
I stopped in the middle of the afternoon and had a wonderful sandwich. I can't wait to try your pizza because I have heard it is wonderful!! How nice to have you in FDL.....we need some diversity! I look forward to trying some of your olives and hope for more offerings in the future. WELCOME! 

Antonio:
We just found you tonight and I picked up some delicious olives. We will be back tomorrow after my pregnant wife dreams about what she will have to eat! We are both very happy to have a nice, authentic Italian deli to go to in town! Benvenuti!  

Jenny:
From the girls at St. Agnes (nurses station) We just had to try you out...we are soooo thankful we did. Between all of us, we tried everything but the pizza (so far)..and can't wait to do so. Sandwiches and desserts were the best!  It's been several hours since our feast and we're all still talking about your scrumptious food. You will do very well here. Welcome to Fond du lac.  

New York Davin:
I cannot thank you guys enough for bringing something I miss soooo much from back home. The food is incredible And the hospitality you have displayed to me is second to none. You have most deffinetly earned yourself a customer for life  

Stefanie Kressaty:
We came by this past weekend and tried your fabulous pizza -- we just can't say enough about it! I live in Chicago so I don't have to go far to find good pizza. I'd put yours up against the best I've had here, New York OR in my travels through Italy. Full of flavor and absolutely delicious! Great spot if you're a "foodie!"

mike:
Buona fortuna voi ed alla vostra famiglia! 04-Sep-0771.87.18.x
brad: This Is A great Pizza Cannot get enough.... 

Kim:
We stopped in 2 days ago and I have not stopped thinking about the cannoli. It was absolutely delicious!

Tricia :
I came in for lunch with a girlfriend, and after watching Chris make a pizza, I'm heading back for dinner with my fianc?who just happens to be Italian). GREAT atmosphere and even better food. Welcome to the neighborhood and good luck!

Sara Cujak:
Chris was great working with me to get Foccica bread. It was wonderful! Good Luck and I can't wait to come in and try your cannoli! 

Colleen:
My husband stopped last night and bought a pizza and meatball sub. It was terrific. I had the leftovers for supper tonight. Good luck to you and we will be visiting again real soon. 

Brian Carter:
The pizza was delicious, many successes to you! 

Paullykins:
I absolutely loved the pizza and meatball sandwich!!! how do you make those meatballs so fluffy? excellent, you guys are going to be a huge sucess! good luck, and God Bless